# Did the 1889 railroad remittance and the 1890 agent’s account give the same amount and prove every recipient was paid?

**Finding 3357 — No. The 1889 commissioner described $6,066.18 for tribal right-of-way compensation plus $295.50 for one affected person, a $6,361.68 check sent to Agent Cole on August 5, 1889.**

In his August 1890 report, Cole says he enrolled the Coeur d’Alene people and that on August 23, 1889 “they were paid” $6,362.32. The scan clearly prints those cents, **64 cents more** than the earlier combined check; moreover the commissioner distinguished tribal and individual shares whereas Cole’s sentence calls the amount due “them.” This is stronger retrospective evidence of a distribution than the earlier future-tense remittance, but neither report supplies the signed roll, Tu-tu’s individual receipt, explanation of the 64 cents, or a complete audit. Do not infer either theft or universal receipt.

**Source and method.** Hal J. Cole, “Report of Colville Agency,” August 11, 1890, *Annual Report of the Commissioner of Indian Affairs for 1890*, printed p. 217; [DOI original scan, PDF leaf 204](https://www.doi.gov/sites/default/files/T-21922.pdf#page=204). [1889 commissioner, printed p. 37, PDF leaf 47](https://archive.org/download/annualreportofco188900unitrich/annualreportofco188900unitrich.pdf#page=47) and [earlier finding 2696](2696-coeur-dalene-railway-remittance-not-distribution-1888-1889.md) distinguish the check and intended shares. The Colville report begins beneath the Utah agent’s signature on p. 216 and ends above Neah Bay on p. 222; this reads the scan against imperfect OCR, preserving the difference between an agent’s retrospective account, a forecast, an authorization and independently proved outcome.
