# 2820. Did 630 Devil’s Lake allotments proceed without any contest in 1890?

**Finding.** In a Devil’s Lake Agency report dated **September 10, 1890**, the agent praised Special Agent **Joseph R. Gray** for the “complete success” of allotment work after an earlier attempt had proved unsuccessful. He wrote that, “out of the 630 in whole or partial allotments made up to date,” there was “absolutely not one contest,” and that no individual was known to him who had a “bad heart” from believing that the allotment had caused injury or injustice. He gave the total area “allotted up to date” as **62,340 acres**. These figures and the absence-of-contest statement are **the agent’s contemporaneous report**, not an independently audited register of agreements or grievances.

His own introduction qualifies his vantage point: he had entered the office only on **July 1** and said he was not yet sufficiently familiar with conditions to give more than “very meager information on many points.” The earlier failed allotment attempt is mentioned but not dated or explained. “Whole or partial allotments” does **not** mean 630 completed trust patents, 630 distinct consenting adults, or equal parcels; dividing 62,340 by 630 would conceal the mixed status of those allotments. Likewise, “not one contest” and no **known** dissatisfied individual do not establish unanimous, unpressured consent or the absence of objections beyond the agent’s knowledge.

The printed passage offers no allotment schedule, claimant or contest docket, patent numbers, survey returns, statements from individual residents, or resolution of the earlier failed effort. Those records and community accounts would be needed to test the scope of Gray’s work and the agent’s broad characterization. This is evidence of **what the agency reported by September 1890**, not proof of completed legal title or an exhaustive search for dissent.

**Primary source:** [*Annual Report of the Commissioner of Indian Affairs*, 1890, “Report of Devil’s Lake Agency,” dated September 10, 1890, printed pp. 25–26 (PDF leaves 108–109)](https://www.doi.gov/sites/default/files/T-21922.pdf#page=109); dated heading and July 1 qualification on [PDF leaf 108](https://www.doi.gov/sites/default/files/T-21922.pdf#page=108). The allotment paragraph was checked against the original printed page image, not OCR alone.
