# Finding 2638 — The missing 5,000 acres were introduced in a later reprint, not the 1883 reservoir report

**Question.** Why does a 1889 commission's reprint of the 1883 Chippewa reservoir-damage letter give a 46,920-acre total but lake subtotals adding to 51,920 acres?

**Finding.** The **original 1884 congressional printing** of Commissioner H. Price's December 19, 1883 letter gives **23,240 acres** for the Winibigoshish reservoir and **23,680 acres** for the Leech Lake reservoir: precisely **46,920 acres**. The later printing in the 1889 commission report instead gives Leech Lake **28,680**, while preserving both Winibigoshish **23,240** and total **46,920**. Thus the 5,000-acre arithmetical discrepancy is a **documentary transmission/printing change in the reprint**, not a conflict within the original letter. An enclosed **October 19, 1883** table signed by assistant engineer **Carswell McClellan** independently decomposes Leech Lake's 23,680 into **11,520 acres attributed to the Chippewa band + 12,160 to the Leech Lake band**. It decomposes Winibigoshish's 23,240 as **3,840 Winibigoshish + 200 Cass Lake + 19,200 Chippewa**. These are contemporaneous *approximate flowage estimates*, not measurements of actual subsequent inundation.

**Evidence and comparison.**

- House Executive Document **76**, 48th Congress, first session, *Damages to Chippewa Indians*, transmitted February 4, 1884, [title and transmittal, printed p. 1 / scan 757](https://api.digitale-sammlungen.de/iiif/image/v2/bsb11683042_00757/full/full/0/default.jpg), [Price letter opening, p. 2 / scan 758](https://api.digitale-sammlungen.de/iiif/image/v2/bsb11683042_00758/full/full/0/default.jpg), and [acreage paragraph, p. 3 / scan 759](https://api.digitale-sammlungen.de/iiif/image/v2/bsb11683042_00759/full/full/0/default.jpg): “only **46,920 acres**, instead of **101,940 acres**” and “Winibigoshish Reservoirs **23,240 acres**, Leech Lake Reservoir **23,680 acres**.” The digits were checked directly against the page image, not just OCR.
- The same original document, [p. 24 / scan 780](https://api.digitale-sammlungen.de/iiif/image/v2/bsb11683042_00780/full/full/0/default.jpg), prints McClellan's October 19 table with both lake totals, all five band-attributed components, and the sentence “The total acreage for the reservoirs amounts to **46,920**.” The estimates use a flowage line **14 feet above 1878 water for Winibigoshish** and **4 feet above 1874 water for Leech Lake**. The surrounding engineer letter says the mapped full flowage **might never be reached**, depending on reservoir operation.
- House Executive Document **247**, 51st Congress, first session, the later Chippewa commission report, [printed p. 19 / scan 411](https://api.digitale-sammlungen.de/iiif/image/v2/bsb11683158_00411/full/full/0/default.jpg), reprints the Price passage with **28,680** for Leech Lake. That is **5,000 greater** than the 1884 printing and McClellan table; 23,240 + 28,680 = **51,920**, not 46,920. This is a check of two scanned printed editions, not an OCR variant.

**Limit.** The comparison locates the **published numerical mutation**, but the typesetter's copy, intervening manuscript, and editorial process are unexamined: it does not identify who introduced the digit or why. The original's arithmetic coherence does not establish the acreage actually flooded, compensation due, or disbursement. See [finding 2627](2627-reservoir-overflow-acreage-subtotals-1883-reprint.md) for the earlier identification of the reprint's internal discrepancy and its distinct damage figures.
