# Flat Mouth’s 1880 Rice memorial resurfaced at the 1889 Leech Lake council

**Finding 2630 · 4 October 1880 statement reprinted in 12 August 1889 proceedings**

## Question

Did the 1889 Pillager grievance about the 1847 Leaf River/Long Prairie cession rest only on later oral recollection, or did participants put an earlier written statement into the council record?

## Evidence

At Leech Lake on **12 August 1889**, a speaker handed commissioner **Henry M. Rice** a paper described as one Rice had given the Pillagers **nine years before**, so it could be shown if anything happened to him. The proceeding then prints a statement dated **St. Paul, 4 October 1880**, made “at the request of Flat Mouth, chief of the Pillager Indians” and signed in print **Henry M. Rice, One of the Commissioners**. It says the 1847 Leaf River cession was understood to allow friendly Menominee residence and a buffer against Sioux warfare, but that later arrangements disappointed those expectations. It estimates about **1,000,000 acres**, calls the sale positive, and says: **“The Pillagers have no legal claim to the land, but morally have a claim upon the Government.”** Rice proposes possible future aid, not a liquidated amount or a payment order. [Printed p. 125, scan 517](https://api.digitale-sammlungen.de/iiif/image/v2/bsb11683158_00517/full/full/0/default.jpg).

In his recorded response Rice said the expectation of Menominee use was understood between him and Flat Mouth, that he had supplied the statement for preservation, and that he knew of no surviving fellow commissioner or witness to the original cession. The transcript is evidence of what he **said in 1889**, not independent proof about every potential witness or the 1847 negotiations. [Printed p. 125, scan 517](https://api.digitale-sammlungen.de/iiif/image/v2/bsb11683158_00517/full/full/0/default.jpg). The [1847 Pillager treaty, 9 Stat. 908](https://treaties.okstate.edu/treaties/treaty-with-the-pillager-band-of-chippewa-indians-1847-0569) defines the tract but does **not** expressly state a Menominee-settlement guarantee; the [1848 Menominee treaty, 9 Stat. 952](https://treaties.okstate.edu/treaties/treaty-with-the-menominee-1848-0572) separately assigns land from the prior cession, and the [1854 Menominee treaty, 10 Stat. 1064](https://treaties.okstate.edu/treaties/treaty-with-the-menominee-1854-0626) recedes the western assignment.

## Resolution and limits

This is a **dated written memorial reproduced in the 1889 proceeding**, with an explicit moral-versus-legal distinction attributed to the 1847 commissioner and a documented act of Indigenous preservation and presentation. It materially strengthens the provenance of the grievance compared with the later commission’s summary alone; see [finding 2626](2626-long-prairie-pillager-menominee-cession-equitable-claim-1889.md). Yet the **physical 1880 paper, signature and custody trail have not been independently inspected**. The reprint does not transform reported oral understandings into the written 1847 treaty, establish a court ruling that no legal claim could ever exist, verify the acreage/valuation estimate, or prove redress was paid.

## Source trail

- *Chippewa Indians in Minnesota*, House documents, 51st Congress, 1st session, vol. 32, Doc. 247, fourth Leech Lake council, pp. [124](https://api.digitale-sammlungen.de/iiif/image/v2/bsb11683158_00516/full/full/0/default.jpg)–[125](https://api.digitale-sammlungen.de/iiif/image/v2/bsb11683158_00517/full/full/0/default.jpg); embedded statement dated 4 October 1880.
- [Pillager treaty of 1847](https://treaties.okstate.edu/treaties/treaty-with-the-pillager-band-of-chippewa-indians-1847-0569); [Menominee treaties of 1848](https://treaties.okstate.edu/treaties/treaty-with-the-menominee-1848-0572) and [1854](https://treaties.okstate.edu/treaties/treaty-with-the-menominee-1854-0626).

**First-solved contribution:** recovered the dated 1880 memorial within the 1889 council record and separated its contemporaneous moral-claim testimony from the text of the controlling treaties.
