# 2294. Which case was John B. Bigboy's timber-money test, and what did it actually decide?

**Resolution.** The case is *Hitchcock, Secretary of the Interior v. United States ex rel. Bigboy*, **22 App. D.C. 275–288** (Court of Appeals of the District of Columbia, June 25, 1903; No. 1294). John Baptiste Bigboy, a Bad River Chippewa allottee, sought the balance of his proceeds from timber sold from his restricted allotment. The **Supreme Court of the District of Columbia** had ordered mandamus against the Secretary of the Interior and Commissioner of Indian Affairs; the D.C. appellate court **reversed with costs** and ordered dismissal of the petition. This identifies the lower-court win and appellate reversal described by La Pointe agent S. W. Capen.

**The actual holding.** Bigboy's 1894 patent restricted alienation without presidential consent. Timber sold under the 1893 regulations produced a reported **$1,144.05 net deposit** in the Ashland National Bank, from which small amounts had been paid. The regulation required the Indian agent to countersign the owner's withdrawal checks. The parties disputed whether countersignature merely verified identity or allowed the government to control withdrawals. The appellate court found **no plain ministerial duty of the Secretary or Commissioner enforceable by mandamus** and expressly treated the ultimate meaning and legal reach of the proceeds restriction as potentially **“an open question”** (pp. 286–288). Citizenship did not itself resolve property restrictions, but the court did **not** order full payment, decide that every monthly cap was lawful, or adjudicate Capen's predictions about recipients' conduct.

**Remaining limit.** Capen asserted that the suit reached the **Supreme Court of the United States**, while the identified published reversal is by the **Court of Appeals of the District of Columbia** from the district's similarly named trial court. No U.S. Supreme Court docket action, opinion, mandate, or later payment record has yet been identified. The agency assertion is not independent proof of a further merits decision. His claim that other Indigenous people funded the test case appears in the agency report, not in the appellate opinion.

**Primary sources.** [Appellate opinion, 22 App. D.C. 275–288](https://static.case.law/app-dc/22/case-pdfs/0275-01.pdf) ([searchable transcription](https://static.case.law/app-dc/22/html/0275-01.html)); *Annual Report of the Commissioner of Indian Affairs for 1903*, printed p. 352, [PDF leaf 183](https://www.doi.gov/sites/default/files/T-21935.pdf#page=183).
