# 2256. Did Port Madison’s birth–death balance prove schooling improved health?

**Resolution.** Bartow reported **five more births than deaths** in the year, the first such balance in the three years since the school opened, and associated it with education and improved homes.

**Evidence and limits.** Neither underlying birth and death counts nor a comparison design appears. The net +5 is his report; a causal school-health effect is unproved.

**Source.** *Annual Report of the Commissioner of Indian Affairs for 1903*, printed p. 340, [PDF leaf 177](https://www.doi.gov/sites/default/files/T-21935.pdf#page=177).
